Perfect Arrangementpostcard advertisement
By Topher Payne
Review by Ernest Edwards
This 2014 play about lavender marriages during height of McCarthyism during the 1950’s feels even more necessary to see now in 2026 than when Theatre in the Round produced this play in June of 2022.
The play takes place in the Georgetown neighborhood of Washington, DC in 1950. Bob Martindale is high up in the State Department and is married to Millie Martindale, their neighbors are Jim Baxter who is married to Norma Baxter. Normal also works with Bob at the State Department. Bob and Jim are a couple, as are Millie and Norma.
While hosting a dinner party for of his boss Ted Sanderson and his wife Kitty, Bob is assigned with expanding his search from rooting out Communists to also include deviants. Such as people who are promiscuous, and homosexuals. Kitty no longer allows her husband Ted to go to the Opera, because the Opera might turn him gay. Really, that is what they believed. Bob, Norma, Jim and Millie are all concerned. Will they be found out? Can they keep hiding in plain sight? How long before their Perfect Arrangement falls apart.
The arrival of State employee Barbara Grant and her past connection to Millie is all it takes for everything to start to unravel.
Director John Heimbuch has assembled a great cast to tell this story. Bob is played by Joe Swanson, Millie is played by Elora Riley, Norma is played by Rachel Postle, Jim is played by Theo Janie-Furman, Ted Sunderson is played by Peter Colburn, Kitty Sunderson is played by Julie Ann Nevill, and Barbara Grant is played fabulously by Lily Rains.
The scenery was reminiscent and based on the set of the I Love Lucy television series from the 1950’s. The costumes designed by Mandi Johnson are gorgeous looking. We were definitely in the 1950’s with her costume design.
This well written play, is a great slice of history that many don’t know about. It’s funny, it’s dramatic, the performances by the cast are perfect for this story that takes place in the 1950’s. This play is perfect to be shown during Pride month
This play is currently playing at the Crane Theater through June 21, 2026. Check out www.walkingshadow.org for tickets.